They walk amongst us and sit next to us. These people are our friends and colleagues. You know who they are; they can be identified by a hand-raising twitch, an incessant urge to share opinions and the seeming inability to allow a point to go uncommented upon. We collectively refer to these individuals as “gunners,” however to oversimplify their existence as one homogeneous group does us a disservice. There are in fact many distinguishable groups that exhibit the characteristics that we normally associate with the larger subgroup, “gunners”. For instance, let us submit the “self conscious under-achiever”; this student does not share his views as a result of some psychological inability to remain still. In fact, the foundation for this student’s conduct is a nagging suspicion that everyone around him thinks he does not belong. In response, our subject overcompensates in order to present himself in supremely capable, competent and thoughtful manner.
Like the “self-conscious under-achiever,” there is another “gunner” whom exhibits his neurosis for voluntary reasons. This student has a far more nuanced and rational reason to be so socially engaged in the classroom. Of course, I am referring to the “distinguished class participator.” The distinguished class participator seeks to dominate the classroom discussion because he or she wants the professor to give them the “Distinguished Classroom Participation”[1] mark on their transcript. The idea being, that this mark will make them stand out amongst other job applicants and give them the upper hand when hiring decisions are made. There are two major arguments made for the efficacy of battling for this designation: (1) Immersion argument; Forcing oneself to constantly be engaged in classroom participation requires a greater understanding and immersion in the reading, which in itself will be beneficial come test-taking time, and (2) Employment argument; when an interviewer sees my “Distinguished Class Participation” mark he will be more likely to hire me than in its absence (especially if my grade in the class is less than exemplary), and thus it is a wise move for job-seekers to dominate the class discussion in pursuit of this mark. I will contend that only the first reason has any merit, and that it is just one of many motivating tools one could use to be actively engaged in the material, thus not truly an argument for the “Distinguished Class Participation” mark at all (see, being engaged to establish a relationship with the professor and secure an internship or reference).
As to the second argument, I must begin by disclosing that, to my knowledge, there has not been any studies conducted detailing the real benefits that a “Distinguished Class Participation” mark has on employment opportunities. As such, any claim of a benefit received from this designation must be considered conjecture only, or anecdotal at best. Here we are dealing with an assumption based upon someone’s logical association of the mark with the potential for an interviewer’s favorable view of the applicant. No one would argue with the feasibility of the assertion; that upon observing that a candidate was awarded for his class participation, an interviewer may look favorably on that applicant’s potential candidacy. However, that is not the only logical assertion that can be drawn. Isn’t it equally as feasible, given that “gunners,” as an identifiable group, are usually looked at with disdain by the rest of the law student community, and that law students eventually become recruiters for legal positions, that an interviewer may have a negative association with that mark? Could the reality be that when an interviewer is faced with the application of a “distinguished class participator,” he is actually less likely to look favorably on that application than if there were no designation at all?
Let us look at the law student opinion of these “gunners” generally: we cringe when their mouths open, we tune out large portions of the class because we refuse to give them our attention and we know they are only talking so that the professor will be aware of their existence. We talk about them behind their back, roll our eyes when we see them in the hall and make videos depicting their buffoonery.[2] As one law student aptly put it, “you know if you crunch the numbers and find out how much you are paying for that class, you feel like they just took $20 out of your pocket.”[3] Furthermore, these individuals steer the classroom discussion away from relevant subjects in order to inject topics they feel more comfortable discussing. “They take the classroom hostage and prevent the larger group from getting out of the material what the professor intends,” exclaimed Jessica Morton ’11. In fact, many students feel they have nothing important to contribute at all and add nothing to the overall enrichment of the class. Tanasha Bennett ’10 offers that while distinguished class participators speak often, “they only have useless information and appear to talk just to hear their own voices.” Some believe that the resentment of “gunners” stems from the fact that they diminish the educational returns of a traditional law school classroom. “Everyone dislikes gunners because they don't give an opportunity for reflective thought, nor do they allow for others to participate,” argued Tara Trout, JD/Psy. D student at Widener University School of Law. This overall negative depiction suggests a clear consensus among the law student community.
Is this consensus echoed amongst professionals in the field as well? In order to support my theory, the negative opinions shared by the majority of law students must remain when these individuals become professionals. If professionals fail to remain hostile towards gunners, we as academics have no empirical basis to argue that the “Distinguished Class Participation” mark will have any negative employment effects.
We, in fact, found that many professionals in practice share the same sentiment as the law students. They vividly remember how students in their classes would monopolize time and discussions. They proclaimed that these students had more bark than bite and that their performance did not correlate with the amount of class time they took up. They argued that one’s time would be better spent finding other means to stand out in the law student application pool. In fact, some believe that in our current economic downturn the mark is meaningless at best. Radiance Walters, an associate at a large law firm in Washington D.C. defends “especially in this economy, it is all about the grades and extracurriculars such as moot court, trial team, journal, etc. and NOT about whether you can talk the most in class. I had plenty of classmates who sat in the front of class, talked a lot in class, graduated with distinguished [DCP] honors and still graduated without a job." Some attorneys were less kind in their explanations of the award. Kenny Oh, a judicial clerk in Philadelphia, proclaimed “getting the DCP award is kind of like winning an 8th grade spelling bee, it feels nice, but after a while you get embarrassed about telling anyone." Overall, this group argues that students will be better served if they find other means to advocate for themselves in the job hunt.
However, some professionals take a more neutral view of the mark. They take the position that the designation has a negligible effect on hiring potential. Judge Daniel Anders explains, “based upon my own participation level in law school, I do not believe a DCP mark is necessarily reflective of someone's performance as an attorney, as a result, it would not be a significant influence in whether I would hire someone.” In fact, when making employment decisions many attorneys pay no attention to the mark at all. Daquana Carter, who sat on the summer associate hiring committee for Pepper Hamilton, LLP, explains, “this statement just seems like an excuse for a student that participates a lot in class and seems knowledgeable, but doesn't do well on a test. Maybe I am assuming too much, but that is why I would rely more on their grades than this statement. The statement alone does nothing to help them get recommended for a position.” Under this group’s rationale, recruiters essentially ignore the designation entirely as they see it as an unhelpful determinant of professional success. To them, the mark is a mere distraction amidst a larger pool of relevant information.
There are detractors, however. Most notably, David Sonnenshein, Professor at Temple University School of Law, argues “when a student comes to me looking for a recommendation or reference, given the sheer volume of students that enter my classrooms, the ‘Distinguished Class Participation’ mark helps me to remember specifically what that student contributed in my class allowing me to give them a better recommendation.” He went on further to argue that having the mark “couldn’t hurt,” and that these distinctions can only set you apart from the pack. Another argument from this side is that the mark signals to an employer that a candidate has certain qualities that are indicative of good work ethic. A mark can tell the employer that the candidate has initiative, plans and prepares his assignments and that he has a serious approach to the material.
So what does this research tell us? Well, immediately we must conclude that while an argument for the potential benefits of a “Distinguished Class Participation” mark are plausible, it is equally plausible that this effort-filled pursuit is a detriment to your employment prospects. In the future more research will be necessary, specifically to determine why students who hate “gunners,” in some instances, become professionals who hire them. There is a seeming disconnect between the opinions of professionals and students, which is odd considering that all professionals were at one time, students. One could argue that at least part of this shift in opinion results from professors, who have a vested interest in encouraging class participation, as it increases the quality of their lessons. Therefore, they may view class participation as more valuable than others by virtue of their professional perspective. Could there be a professor bias regarding the opinions towards the DCP? Does the animus towards distinguished class participators diminish the longer one is out of law school? Any number of reasons could conceivably account for the increasingly positive relative opinion that lawyers have of these individuals after graduation. Until we uncover the reasons behind this disconnect, law students will be unable to properly weigh benefits against the social costs inherent in undertaking the time required to be a distinguished class participator.
No comments:
Post a Comment